Jump to content

Skill Dual Wield: Difference between revisions

From EverQuest Legends Wiki
← Older edit
Maergoth (talk | contribs)
Bureaucrats, Interface administrators, Administrators
13,261 edits
VisualWikitext
No edit summary
 
(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 7: Line 7:
The calculator provides a target-neutral comparison between two one-handed weapons and one two-handed weapon.
The calculator provides a target-neutral comparison between two one-handed weapons and one two-handed weapon.


It is a '''normalized weapon comparison''', not a complete average-DPS simulator. Its result is most useful when comparing weapons on the same character against the same type of target, particularly when the relevant weapon skills are similarly trained.
It is a '''normalized weapon comparison''', not a complete average-DPS simulator. Its result is most useful when comparing weapons on the same character against the same target when the relevant weapon skills are similarly trained.


=== Calculator Score ===
=== Calculator Score ===


The calculator uses the traditional weapon-score benchmark:
The calculator uses the traditional normalized weapon-score comparison:


<pre>
<pre>
Primary round multiplier =
    1
    + P(Double Attack)
    + P(Double Attack) × P(Triple Attack)
      × Flurry Factor
Main-hand score =
Main-hand score =
     ((2 × Main Damage) + Main-Hand Damage Bonus)
     (((2 × Main Damage) + Main-Hand Damage Bonus)
     ÷ Main Delay
     ÷ Main Delay)
    × Primary round multiplier
 
Offhand round multiplier =
    1 + P(Double Attack)


Offhand score =
Offhand score =
     Modeled Dual Wield Chance
     Modeled Dual Wield Chance
     × ((2 × Offhand Damage) ÷ Offhand Delay)
     × ((2 × Offhand Damage) ÷ Offhand Delay)
    × Offhand round multiplier


Dual Wield score =
Dual Wield score =
Line 26: Line 37:


Two-Hander score =
Two-Hander score =
     ((2 × Two-Hander Damage) + Two-Hand Damage Bonus)
     (((2 × Two-Hander Damage) + Two-Hand Damage Bonus)
     ÷ Two-Hander Delay
     ÷ Two-Hander Delay)
    × Primary round multiplier
</pre>
</pre>


The factor of <code>2 × damage</code> is a traditional comparison benchmark sometimes called the weapon's "magic number." It should not be interpreted as the exact average damage of every successful hit.
The <code>Flurry Factor</code> is <code>1</code> without Burst of Power and <code>1.225</code> with Burst of Power under the current working model.
 
The factor of <code>2 × damage</code> is a comparison benchmark, not the exact average damage of every successful hit.


The calculator automatically tests both one-handed arrangements:
The calculator automatically tests both one-handed arrangements:
Line 37: Line 51:
* Weapon B in primary and Weapon A in secondary.
* Weapon B in primary and Weapon A in secondary.


This is necessary because the primary weapon attacks whenever its own timer is ready, while the secondary weapon's attack opportunity is additionally limited by the Dual Wield check.
This matters because the primary and secondary weapons swing independently, but the secondary weapon's attack opportunity is additionally gated by the Dual Wield check.


The calculator does not currently model:
The calculator does not currently model:


* Hit rate or target avoidance.
* Target avoidance or exact hit rate.
* Different weapon-skill values or skill caps.
* Unequal weapon-skill values.
* STR, ATK, Offense, or target mitigation.
* STR, ATK, Offense, or target mitigation.
* Double Attack, Triple Attack, flurry, critical hits, or special attacks.
* Critical hits and special attacks other than Double Attack, Triple Attack, and Burst of Power.
* Proc damage or hand-specific proc rates.
* Proc damage or hand-specific proc behavior.
* Haste rounding, minimum-delay rules, or other timer rounding.
* Haste rounding, minimum-delay rules, or other timer rounding.
* Stances, invocations, disciplines, or temporary combat modifiers.
* Stances, invocations, disciplines, or temporary combat modifiers.
Line 58: Line 72:
'''Confirmed on EverQuest Legends:''' the primary and secondary weapons use independent attack timers.
'''Confirmed on EverQuest Legends:''' the primary and secondary weapons use independent attack timers.


Each weapon uses its own delay. A fast secondary weapon may therefore reach multiple offhand attack opportunities before a slower primary weapon reaches its next attack.
Each weapon uses its own delay. A fast secondary weapon can therefore reach multiple offhand attack opportunities before a slower primary weapon reaches its next attack.


Equipping a slower primary weapon does not directly slow the secondary weapon, and equipping a slower secondary weapon does not directly slow the primary weapon.
Equipping a slower primary weapon does not directly slow the secondary weapon, and equipping a slower secondary weapon does not directly slow the primary weapon.
Line 64: Line 78:
=== Offhand Attack Opportunities ===
=== Offhand Attack Opportunities ===


When the secondary weapon's timer becomes ready, the game performs a Dual Wield check. A successful check permits the secondary attack opportunity to proceed; a failed check produces no secondary attack for that timer cycle.
When the secondary weapon's timer becomes ready, the game performs a Dual Wield check.
 
A successful check permits the secondary attack opportunity to proceed. A failed check produces no secondary attack for that timer cycle.
 
Higher Dual Wield skill therefore increases the percentage of secondary timer opportunities that become attacks. It does not change the secondary weapon's listed delay.
 
=== Damage Bonus Is a Separate Flat Addition ===
 
Weapon damage bonus is treated separately from the rolled weapon-damage portion of an attack.
 
STR, ATK, Offense, weapon skill, and target mitigation affect the variable weapon-damage roll. They do not directly determine the displayed weapon damage-bonus value.
 
Under the ordinary EverQuest hand model used by the calculator:
 
* An eligible primary-hand attack receives the weapon's damage bonus.
* The ordinary secondary-hand attack receives no damage bonus.
* A two-handed primary weapon receives its own damage bonus.
* Damage bonus is applied per eligible primary-hand hit.
 
This means the damage bonus must be calculated for the '''specific weapon placed in primary'''. It is not a single universal one-handed value.


=== Primary and Secondary Hand Assignment ===
=== Primary and Secondary Hand Assignment ===


At less than 100% Dual Wield chance, hand assignment matters for two reasons:
At less than 100% Dual Wield chance, hand assignment matters because:


# The primary weapon attacks on every eligible primary timer cycle.
# The primary weapon attacks whenever its own timer is ready.
# The secondary weapon contributes only when its Dual Wield check succeeds.
# The secondary weapon attacks only when its own timer is ready '''and''' the Dual Wield check succeeds.


The calculator therefore tests both possible hand assignments rather than relying on a universal "best weapon goes in secondary" rule.
The calculator therefore tests both hand assignments automatically.


Using <code>P</code> for Dual Wield chance, the difference between placing Weapon A or Weapon B in primary depends on both:
In general, the stronger base weapon score becomes more valuable in primary as Dual Wield chance falls, because primary attacks are not reduced by the Dual Wield success check.
 
=== Primary-Hand Choice at High Dual Wield Chance ===
 
The higher the Dual Wield chance becomes, the less hand assignment matters because fewer offhand timer opportunities are lost.
 
Under the current Legends working chance model, a capped Monk at 252 Dual Wield skill has:


<pre>
<pre>
(1 − P) × difference in base weapon score
252 ÷ 400 = 63.00% base chance


and
63.00% × 1.32 Ambidexterity
= 83.16% modeled chance
</pre>


Damage Bonus × difference in attack frequency
This means even a capped Monk with Ambidexterity is not currently expected to reach 100% Dual Wield chance.
 
Because the offhand is still losing some attack opportunities, the weapon with the stronger base <code>(2 × Damage) ÷ Delay</code> value will generally benefit from being placed in the primary hand.
 
Once Triple Attack is available, primary-hand placement becomes even more important because the primary weapon can receive Triple Attack and Burst of Power flurries while the offhand cannot.
 
The calculator nevertheless tests both arrangements because Damage Bonus, unusual weapon damage, delays above the Damage Bonus cap, and other hand-specific mechanics can affect the result.
 
Under the unrounded working Damage Bonus formula, ordinary one-handed weapons with damage at or below character level and delay at or below 50 receive approximately the same Damage Bonus contribution per unit time. For this reason, speculative integer Damage Bonus rounding should not normally override the advantage of putting the stronger-ratio weapon in primary.
=== Double Attack, Triple Attack, and Burst of Power ===
 
The calculator now includes additional melee attacks because Triple Attack is not available to the offhand and therefore does '''not''' cancel evenly between Dual Wield and two-handed setups.
 
==== Double Attack ====
 
Double Attack is modeled as available to both primary-hand and secondary-hand attack rounds.
 
The current working chance formula is:
 
<pre>
Double Attack Chance =
    (Character Level + Current Double Attack Skill)
    ÷ 500
</pre>
</pre>


This means the preferred primary weapon may be:
The currently documented Legends acquisition levels and maximum skills are:
 
{| class="eoTable2" style="width:75%"
|-
! Class !! Minimum Level !! Maximum Skill
|-
| '''[[Monk]]''' || 15 || 250
|-
| '''[[Warrior]]''' || 15 || 245
|-
| '''[[Rogue]]''' || 16 || 240
|-
| '''[[Paladin]]''' || 20 || 235
|-
| '''[[Shadowknight]]''' || 20 || 235
|-
| '''[[Ranger]]''' || 20 || 235
|-
| '''[[Berserker]]''' || 15 || 250
|}


* The weapon with the stronger damage-to-delay value.
When Actual DA Skill is blank, the calculator provisionally uses <code>Level × 5</code>, capped by the class maximum. Entering the actual skill overrides this assumption.
* The weapon with the lower delay, allowing more frequent primary-hand damage bonuses.
* A compromise between those two advantages.


=== Hand Assignment at 100% Dual Wield Chance ===
==== Triple Attack ====


At exactly 100% Dual Wield chance, the ordinary weapon-damage contributions of the same two weapons are identical regardless of which hand holds them.
'''Current Legends observation: Triple Attack does not occur from the offhand.'''


Under a primary-only damage-bonus model, the only remaining difference is how frequently the primary-hand damage bonus is applied.
The calculator therefore allows Triple Attack only on the primary hand and on two-handed attack rounds.
 
{| class="eoTable2" style="width:70%"
|-
! Class !! Minimum Level !! Maximum Skill
|-
| '''[[Monk]]''' || 46 || 100
|-
| '''[[Warrior]]''' || 46 || 100
|-
| '''[[Rogue]]''' || 46 || 100
|-
| '''[[Ranger]]''' || 46 || 100
|-
| '''[[Berserker]]''' || 46 || 100
|}
 
The current working chance is:
 
<pre>
Triple Attack Chance =
    Triple Attack Skill
    ÷ (Triple Attack Skill + 800)
</pre>
 
Triple Attack is modeled as being checked only after a successful Double Attack.


Therefore:
Therefore:


* Put the '''lower-delay weapon in primary''' when the primary hand receives a positive damage bonus.
<pre>
* Hand assignment does not matter when both weapons have the same delay.
Expected primary / 2H attacks per timer opportunity =
* Hand assignment does not matter when the primary-hand damage bonus is zero, assuming no other hand-specific mechanics apply.
    1
    + P(Double Attack)
    + P(Double Attack) × P(Triple Attack)
</pre>
 
At 100 Triple Attack skill:
 
<pre>
100 ÷ (100 + 800)
= 11.11%
</pre>
 
That 11.11% is conditional on Double Attack already succeeding.
 
When Actual TA Skill is blank, the calculator provisionally models 5 skill points per level beginning at level 46, capped at 100. Entering the actual skill overrides this assumption.
 
==== Burst of Power / Flurry ====
 
Burst of Power is available as a calculator checkbox.
 
The current working interpretation is:
 
* Flurry is checked only after a successful Triple Attack.
* Burst of Power grants a '''15%''' chance to flurry.
* A successful flurry produces either one or two additional attacks.
* The calculator assumes a 50% chance of either outcome.
 
The expected flurry contribution per successful Triple Attack is:
 
<pre>
0.15 × (0.50 × 1 + 0.50 × 2)
= 0.225 extra attacks
</pre>


=== Damage Bonus ===
With Burst of Power enabled:


Weapon damage bonus is a flat amount added to an eligible successful attack. STR and ATK affect the rolled weapon-damage portion of an attack; they do not directly increase the flat damage-bonus value.
<pre>
Primary / 2H multiplier =
    1
    + P(DA)
    + P(DA) × P(TA) × 1.225
</pre>


In the traditional EverQuest model:
The offhand receives Double Attack but does not receive Triple Attack or this Triple-Attack-triggered flurry in the current model:


* The ordinary weapon damage is rolled first.
<pre>
* The appropriate main-hand damage bonus is added afterward.
Offhand multiplier =
* The standard secondary attack receives no primary-hand damage bonus.
    1 + P(Double Attack)
* A two-handed weapon may receive a different damage bonus from a one-handed weapon.
</pre>


The calculator currently follows this traditional primary-only damage-bonus model. The exact Legends damage-bonus rules remain subject to in-game verification as described below.
This creates a real post-level-46 disadvantage for the offhand relative to the primary hand and a two-handed weapon.


=== Shared Modifiers ===
=== Shared Modifiers ===


A modifier that changes both setups by exactly the same proportion does not change which setup wins the normalized comparison.
A modifier that affects both compared setups by the same proportion does not change which setup wins a normalized comparison.


For example, ordinary haste generally accelerates all equipped weapon timers. When the same haste multiplier applies to every compared weapon, it scales both totals together.
Ordinary haste is therefore omitted from the calculator when the same haste applies to all compared weapons.


However, shared effects may stop cancelling perfectly when the game applies:
STR and ATK are also omitted from the simple comparison because the calculator is intended as a target-neutral weapon comparison rather than a complete melee simulator. A full expected-DPS model would require the attacker's combat statistics, the target's mitigation and avoidance, weapon skills, and the damage-roll distribution.


* Integer timer rounding.
== Working Legends Damage Bonus Model ==
* A minimum weapon-delay floor.
 
* Different eligibility rules for primary, secondary, or two-handed attacks.
EverQuest damage-bonus formulas have changed over time.
* Different Double Attack, Triple Attack, or flurry behavior by hand.
 
* Hand-specific proc rates or bonuses.
The older classic-era one-handed formula and historical two-handed lookup tables do '''not''' match observed EverQuest Legends damage bonuses well.
 
The calculator therefore uses a later/live EverQuest damage-bonus formula published by a Daybreak developer. This model closely matches the currently observed Legends values across a range of one-handed and two-handed weapon delays.
 
The working formula is:
 
<pre>
Damage Bonus =
    Hand Modifier
    × max(Character Level, Weapon Damage)
    × (min(Weapon Delay, 50) ÷ 40)
    × (Character Level ÷ 100)
</pre>
 
Where:
 
* '''1H Hand Modifier = 0.8'''
* '''2H Hand Modifier = 1.1'''
* Weapon delay contributes only up to '''50 delay'''.
* If weapon damage exceeds character level, weapon damage is used instead of character level for that portion of the formula.
* Damage bonus begins at level 28 in the reference implementation.
 
The exact Legends integer rounding rule has not yet been proven.
 
For weapon comparison, the calculator therefore uses the '''unrounded''' working Damage Bonus value internally:
 
<pre>
Modifier
× max(Level, Damage)
× (min(Delay, 50) ÷ 40)
× (Level ÷ 100)
</pre>
 
This avoids allowing a speculative rounding rule to determine which one-handed weapon should be placed in primary. The calculator may display an integer Damage Bonus estimate for readability, but the normalized comparison itself uses the raw modeled value.
 
=== Why Delay Matters ===
 
Unlike the older classic one-handed damage-bonus formula, the newer formula scales the damage bonus with weapon delay.
 
This explains why two one-handed weapons at the same character level can display different damage bonuses and why slower two-handed weapons can receive much larger bonuses.
 
Because delay contribution caps at 50:
 
* Increasing delay from 20 to 40 increases modeled damage bonus.
* Increasing delay from 50 to 70 does '''not''' increase the delay portion further.
* A weapon with damage greater than character level can still receive a larger bonus because the formula uses <code>max(Level, Damage)</code>.


== Classes and Skill Caps on Legends ==
== Classes and Skill Caps on Legends ==
Line 141: Line 328:
* [[Warrior]]
* [[Warrior]]


On a three-class character, the calculator uses the highest applicable Dual Wield cap supplied by any of the selected classes. Class caps are not added together.
On a three-class character, the calculator uses the highest applicable Dual Wield cap supplied by any selected class. Class caps are not added together.


The current working level-based cap model is:
The current working level-50 cap model is:


{| class="eoTable2" style="width:70%"
{| class="eoTable2" style="width:70%"
Line 149: Line 336:
! Class
! Class
! Working per-level formula
! Working per-level formula
! Current modeled cap
! Modeled cap through level 50
! Status
! Status
|-
|-
Line 155: Line 342:
| <code>(Level × 5) + 5</code>
| <code>(Level × 5) + 5</code>
| 210
| 210
| Working model; additional Legends observations needed
| Working model
|-
|-
| style="text-align:left"| '''[[Beastlord]]'''
| style="text-align:left"| '''[[Beastlord]]'''
| <code>(Level × 5) + 5</code>
| <code>(Level × 5) + 5</code>
| 210
| 210
| Working model; additional Legends observations needed
| Working model
|-
|-
| style="text-align:left"| '''[[Monk]]'''
| style="text-align:left"| '''[[Monk]]'''
Line 170: Line 357:
| <code>(Level × 5) + 5</code>
| <code>(Level × 5) + 5</code>
| 210
| 210
| Working model; additional Legends observations needed
| Working model
|-
|-
| style="text-align:left"| '''[[Rogue]]'''
| style="text-align:left"| '''[[Rogue]]'''
| <code>(Level × 6) + 5</code>
| <code>(Level × 6) + 5</code>
| 210
| 210
| The per-level formula is documented; additional Legends observations remain useful
| Working model
|-
|-
| style="text-align:left"| '''[[Warrior]]'''
| style="text-align:left"| '''[[Warrior]]'''
| <code>(Level × 5) + 5</code>
| <code>(Level × 5) + 5</code>
| 210
| 210
| Working model; additional Legends observations needed
| Working model
|}
|}


Line 192: Line 379:
</pre>
</pre>


The calculator assumes the character's Dual Wield skill is trained to the applicable cap. A character whose current skill is below cap will have a lower actual offhand success rate than the calculator models.
The calculator assumes the character's Dual Wield skill is trained to the applicable cap unless an actual skill value is entered.


== Era-Dependent and Unconfirmed Mechanics ==
== Era-Dependent and Unconfirmed Mechanics ==


The following mechanics have differed between EverQuest eras, community servers, and emulator implementations. They should not be presented as confirmed EverQuest Legends behavior until tested directly on Legends.
The following mechanics have changed between EverQuest eras or differ among community servers and emulator implementations. Their exact behavior on EverQuest Legends should be confirmed directly rather than inherited from another era.
 
=== Current Dual Wield Chance Model ===
 
The exact server formula has not been proven from source code, but direct Legends parsing now gives a substantially better working model than the inherited historical formulas.
 
The calculator currently uses:
 
<pre>
Base Dual Wield Chance =
    Current Dual Wield Skill ÷ 400
</pre>
 
Character level is '''not''' added directly to the numerator in this model.
 
Level still matters indirectly because it determines how much Dual Wield skill the character can obtain.
 
For a Monk with 252 Dual Wield skill:
 
<pre>
252 ÷ 400 = 63.00%
</pre>
 
With the current Ambidexterity working model:
 
<pre>
63.00% × 1.32 = 83.16%
</pre>
 
==== Legends Parse Evidence ====
 
A level-50 Monk with:
 
* '''252 Dual Wield skill'''
* '''Ambidexterity'''
* '''27-delay primary weapon'''
* '''28-delay secondary weapon'''
* '''+50% haste'''
 
produced a parse of approximately:
 
* '''1,057 primary-hand pierce swings'''
* '''860 offhand punches'''


=== Exact Dual Wield Chance Formula ===
The small 27-versus-28 delay difference is nowhere near large enough to explain the observed swing-count gap by itself.


The exact Legends formula that converts level and Dual Wield skill into offhand success chance is not yet confirmed.
After accounting approximately for the independent 27/28 weapon timers, the parse implies an offhand success rate in the low-to-mid 80% range.


Several incompatible reference models exist:
That is inconsistent with the previous calculator model:


{| class="eoTable2" style="width:85%"
<pre>
|-
(Level + Skill) ÷ 400 × 1.32
! Reference
</pre>
! Chance model
! Status for Legends
|-
| style="text-align:left"| Historical Project 1999 community model
| <code>(Level + Dual Wield Skill) ÷ 400</code>
| Conjectural; not confirmed on Legends
|-
| style="text-align:left"| Historical Project 1999 Warrior estimate
| <code>(Level + Dual Wield Skill) ÷ 475</code>
| Based on outside Warrior testing; not confirmed on Legends
|-
| style="text-align:left"| Other inherited community documentation
| Divisors as high as 600 have been proposed
| Conflicting and unconfirmed
|-
| style="text-align:left"| Current EQEmu client reference implementation
| <code>(Level + Dual Wield Skill + Ambidexterity Value) ÷ 375</code>
| Inspectable implementation, but not proof of Legends behavior
|-
| style="text-align:left"| EverQuest Legends
| '''Unknown'''
| Requires a controlled in-game parse
|}


Because the older <code>400</code> and Warrior-specific <code>475</code> divisors are themselves unverified community estimates, they should not be displayed as settled class mechanics.
which predicted almost 100% for a capped level-50 Monk.


Until a Legends-specific parse is available, the calculator may use a clearly labeled provisional reference model. Its detailed view should always display which model is being used.
It is instead closely consistent with:


=== Ambidexterity ===
<pre>
Skill ÷ 400 × 1.32
</pre>


The Legends description of [[Alternate Advancement|Ambidexterity]] states that it increases the chance to successfully Dual Wield by '''32%'''.
which predicts:


What "32%" means internally has not yet been confirmed. Plausible implementations include:
<pre>
252 ÷ 400 × 1.32
= 83.16%
</pre>


* Multiplying the base success chance by <code>1.32</code>.
This remains a '''working Legends formula''' rather than a proven server-side equation, but it is currently the model best supported by direct in-game evidence.
* Adding 32 percentage points to the final chance.
* Adding a raw value of 32 to the numerator of the Dual Wield check.
* Another server-specific implementation.


The current EQEmu reference implementation treats Ambidexterity as a raw value added to the Dual Wield chance calculation before a roll against 375. Legends may or may not use the same behavior.
Historical formulas such as <code>(Level + Skill) ÷ 400</code>, the Project 1999 Warrior <code>÷475</code> estimate, and current EQEmu implementations should therefore be treated as historical references rather than the active Legends calculator model.
=== Ambidexterity ===


The calculator's Ambidexterity checkbox must therefore identify its handling as a '''working assumption''', not a confirmed Legends formula.
'''Confirmed on EverQuest Legends:''' [[Alternate Advancement|Ambidexterity]] is listed as increasing successful Dual Wield chance by '''32%'''.


=== Damage-Bonus Eligibility and Values ===
The calculator currently treats that value as a multiplicative increase:


Traditional classic-era damage-bonus behavior commonly includes:
<pre>
Effective Dual Wield Chance =
    Base Dual Wield Chance × 1.32
</pre>


* Damage bonuses beginning at level 28 for eligible melee characters.
This interpretation is not proven from Legends source code, but when paired with the skill-only base formula it closely matches current parse evidence.
* A one-handed primary bonus based on character level.
* A two-handed primary bonus based on both character level and weapon delay.
* No ordinary damage bonus for the secondary hand.


A commonly referenced one-handed formula is:
For a capped Monk:


<pre>
<pre>
floor((Level − 25) ÷ 3)
Base:
252 ÷ 400
= 63.00%
 
With Ambidexterity:
63.00% × 1.32
= 83.16%
</pre>
</pre>


This produces:
Additional controlled parses without Ambidexterity would be especially useful for separating the base Dual Wield formula from the exact Ambidexterity implementation.
=== Exact Damage-Bonus Formula and Rounding ===


{| class="eoTable2" style="width:35%"
The later/live formula used by the calculator is currently the best match to observed Legends damage bonuses.
|-
 
! Level
However, Legends-specific confirmation is still needed for:
! One-Handed Bonus
|-
| 28 || 1
|-
| 31 || 2
|-
| 34 || 3
|-
| 37 || 4
|-
| 40 || 5
|-
| 43 || 6
|-
| 46 || 7
|-
| 49 || 8
|}


Two-handed damage-bonus tables have changed across eras and depend on weapon delay. The calculator currently uses a classic-style level-and-delay table as a working model.
* exact integer rounding or truncation,
* whether level 28 is the exact activation level,
* whether the 0.8 and 1.1 handedness modifiers are identical on Legends,
* whether the 50-delay cap is identical,
* whether all multiclass combinations receive damage bonus identically,
* whether any Legends AA, stance, invocation, or item effect grants secondary-hand damage bonus.


The following still require Legends-specific confirmation:
The older classic formula:


* Whether damage bonus begins at level 28.
<pre>
* Whether all Legends melee class combinations qualify identically.
floor((Level − 25) ÷ 3)
* The exact one-handed damage-bonus formula.
</pre>
* The exact two-handed damage-bonus table.
* Whether any Legends AA, stance, invocation, item effect, or class combination grants secondary-hand damage bonus.
* Whether damage bonus is applied before or after any Legends-specific outgoing-damage multiplier.


=== Double Attack, Triple Attack, and Flurry ===
and historical two-handed lookup tables should be treated as '''historical mechanics''', not as the current Legends calculator model.


Additional attacks are excluded from the basic calculator because their relative effect depends on hand-specific eligibility.
=== Additional-Attack Formula Verification ===


Mechanics that require confirmation include:
Double Attack, Triple Attack, and Burst of Power are now included in the calculator using the working formulas above.


* Whether secondary attacks can Double Attack at every Double Attack skill value.
The following still need direct Legends verification:
* Whether the secondary hand has a minimum Double Attack skill requirement.
* Whether a two-handed attack receives any different Double Attack treatment.
* Whether Triple Attack is limited to the primary hand.
* Whether flurry can trigger from primary, secondary, or both.
* Whether class selection changes these rules on a multiclass character.


When the same additional-attack multiplier applies equally to every compared weapon, it cancels from the relative comparison. When eligibility differs by hand, it does not.
* Exact Double Attack probability formula and divisor.
* Exact per-level Double Attack caps.
* Exact Triple Attack probability formula.
* Exact per-level Triple Attack caps.
* Confirmation across eligible multiclass combinations that Triple Attack remains primary-only.
* Exact Burst of Power fourth/fifth-swing procedure.
* Any AA, item, discipline, or stance that changes additional-attack eligibility by hand.


=== Proc Rates ===
=== Proc Rates ===
Line 319: Line 520:
Proc damage is not included because proc behavior may differ by:
Proc damage is not included because proc behavior may differ by:


* Primary versus secondary hand.
* primary versus secondary hand,
* Weapon delay.
* weapon delay,
* Dexterity.
* Dexterity,
* Proc-per-minute normalization.
* proc-per-minute normalization,
* Spellblade or other Legends-specific systems.
* Legends-specific item or AA effects.
* Weapon effects transferred through Legends item customization.


A weaker-ratio weapon with a valuable proc may outperform the calculator's normalized weapon score.
A weaker normalized weapon score can still produce better actual DPS when its proc contribution is sufficiently strong.


=== Skill Acquisition Levels ===
=== Skill Acquisition Levels ===


Current Legends wiki pages contain conflicting inherited information about the level at which Bard, Rogue, Warrior, and other classes acquire Dual Wield.
Historical class tables disagree about the level at which several classes acquire Dual Wield.


Because multiclassing and Legends skill grants differ from historical EverQuest, the skill's acquisition level should be verified in-game for each relevant class rather than copied from historical class tables.
EverQuest Legends multiclassing also differs from historical EverQuest.


The calculator assumes that the character already possesses Dual Wield.
The calculator therefore assumes the character already possesses Dual Wield and focuses on the applicable skill cap.


=== Post-Level-50 Skill Caps ===
=== Post-Level-50 Skill Caps ===


EverQuest Legends currently operates in its level-50 Classic Era.
Historical EverQuest sources commonly list later caps such as:
 
Historical class tables commonly list the following later caps:


* Bard: 210
* Bard: 210
Line 349: Line 547:
* Warrior: 240
* Warrior: 240


These values are not currently reachable Legends behavior and should not be treated as confirmed future Legends caps. They should be retested if the Legends level cap increases.
These should not be treated as confirmed future Legends caps. They should be retested if the Legends level cap increases.


=== Empty-Hand and Primary-Slot Requirements ===
=== Empty-Hand and Primary-Slot Requirements ===


Some traditional implementations require an eligible primary weapon before a secondary weapon can make Dual Wield checks, while Monks may receive special empty-hand behavior.
Historical implementations have differed in their treatment of an empty primary slot, Hand to Hand, and secondary-only weapons.


The following are not yet confirmed on Legends:
The following should be tested directly on Legends:


* Whether a non-Monk can attack with a secondary weapon while the primary slot is empty.
* Whether a non-Monk can attack with a secondary weapon while primary is empty.
* Whether a Monk can use an empty primary hand with a secondary weapon.
* Whether a Monk can use an empty primary hand with a secondary weapon.
* Whether an empty secondary slot can still produce Dual Wield skill checks.
* Whether an empty secondary slot can still trigger Dual Wield checks.
* Whether Hand to Hand attacks use the same independent timers as equipped weapons.
* Whether Hand to Hand uses the same independent-timer behavior as equipped weapons.
 
These behaviors should remain in the unconfirmed section until directly tested.


== Legends Verification Priorities ==
== Legends Verification Priorities ==


The highest-priority tests are:
The highest-priority remaining tests are:


# '''Dual Wield chance:''' use distinguishable primary and secondary attack types, count both successful hits and misses, and compare observed secondary attempts against the number of secondary timer opportunities.
# '''Dual Wield chance:''' repeat long primary/offhand swing-count parses at several known Dual Wield skill values to test the current <code>Skill ÷ 400</code> model.
# '''Ambidexterity:''' repeat the same long parse before and after purchasing Ambidexterity without changing equipment, haste, skills, or target.
# '''Ambidexterity:''' repeat the same controlled parse with and without Ambidexterity to verify the current multiplicative <code>×1.32</code> model.
# '''Damage bonus:''' compare minimum and common hit values using the same weapon in primary and secondary at several character levels.
# '''Damage bonus rounding:''' record level, weapon damage, delay, handedness, and displayed damage bonus for many weapons.
# '''Two-handed damage bonus:''' compare otherwise similar two-handed weapons with different delays at the same level.
# '''Damage bonus activation:''' test levels immediately below and above level 28.
# '''Class skill caps:''' record the displayed cap at each level for every Dual Wield-granting class and for multiclass combinations.
# '''Double Attack:''' parse characters with known DA skill values to test <code>(Level + Skill) ÷ 500</code> and confirm offhand Double Attack.
# '''Additional attacks:''' separately test primary and secondary Double Attack eligibility at several Double Attack skill values.
# '''Triple Attack:''' record primary attack-round distributions at several known TA skill values to test <code>Skill ÷ (Skill + 800)</code>.
# '''Triple Attack hand rule:''' continue checking offhand logs to confirm that Triple Attack never occurs from secondary.
# '''Burst of Power:''' measure fourth- and fifth-swing frequencies after successful Triple Attacks to determine the exact flurry procedure.
# '''Class skill caps:''' record displayed caps by level for every Dual Wield-granting class.


A long parse should count attempted attacks rather than only successful damage, because hit rate is separate from the Dual Wield success check.
For Dual Wield testing, attempted swings should be distinguished from successful hits whenever possible because hit rate is separate from the Dual Wield check.


== Reference Implementations and Historical Sources ==
== References ==


* [[Alternate Advancement]] — current Legends Ambidexterity description.
* [[Alternate Advancement]] — Legends Ambidexterity description.
* [[Game Mechanics]] — inherited community formulas and mechanics notes.
* [[Game Mechanics]] — inherited combat-mechanics notes.
* [https://forums.everquest.com/index.php?threads/ratio-calculation-with-elemental-damage.274525/ EverQuest Forums — Daybreak developer explanation of the normalized weapon damage-bonus formula]
* [https://wiki.project1999.com/Game_Mechanics#Comparing_Weapons Project 1999 Game Mechanics — Comparing Weapons]
* [https://wiki.project1999.com/Game_Mechanics#Comparing_Weapons Project 1999 Game Mechanics — Comparing Weapons]
* [https://wiki.project1999.com/Game_Mechanics#Dual_Wield Project 1999 Game Mechanics — Dual Wield]
* [https://wiki.project1999.com/Game_Mechanics#Dual_Wield Project 1999 Game Mechanics — Dual Wield]
* [https://github.com/EQEmu/EQEmu/blob/master/zone/attack.cpp Current EQEmu attack and Dual Wield reference implementation]
* [https://github.com/EQEmu/EQEmu/blob/master/zone/attack.cpp Current EQEmu combat reference implementation]
* [https://github.com/EQEmu/EQEmu/blob/master/zone/client_process.cpp Current EQEmu primary and secondary timer processing]
* [https://github.com/EQEmu/EQEmu/blob/master/zone/client_process.cpp Current EQEmu primary and secondary timer processing]


Latest revision as of 18:37, 22 August 2026

Dual Wield is the combat skill that allows a character to make attacks with an eligible weapon equipped in the secondary slot while continuing to attack with the primary slot.

Dual Wield Calculator

The calculator provides a target-neutral comparison between two one-handed weapons and one two-handed weapon.

It is a normalized weapon comparison, not a complete average-DPS simulator. Its result is most useful when comparing weapons on the same character against the same target when the relevant weapon skills are similarly trained.

Calculator Score

The calculator uses the traditional normalized weapon-score comparison: 

Primary round multiplier =
    1
    + P(Double Attack)
    + P(Double Attack) × P(Triple Attack)
      × Flurry Factor

Main-hand score =
    (((2 × Main Damage) + Main-Hand Damage Bonus)
    ÷ Main Delay)
    × Primary round multiplier

Offhand round multiplier =
    1 + P(Double Attack)

Offhand score =
    Modeled Dual Wield Chance
    × ((2 × Offhand Damage) ÷ Offhand Delay)
    × Offhand round multiplier

Dual Wield score =
    Main-hand score + Offhand score

Two-Hander score =
    (((2 × Two-Hander Damage) + Two-Hand Damage Bonus)
    ÷ Two-Hander Delay)
    × Primary round multiplier

The Flurry Factor is 1 without Burst of Power and 1.225 with Burst of Power under the current working model.

The factor of 2 × damage is a comparison benchmark, not the exact average damage of every successful hit.

The calculator automatically tests both one-handed arrangements:

  • Weapon A in primary and Weapon B in secondary.
  • Weapon B in primary and Weapon A in secondary.

This matters because the primary and secondary weapons swing independently, but the secondary weapon's attack opportunity is additionally gated by the Dual Wield check.

The calculator does not currently model:

  • Target avoidance or exact hit rate.
  • Unequal weapon-skill values.
  • STR, ATK, Offense, or target mitigation.
  • Critical hits and special attacks other than Double Attack, Triple Attack, and Burst of Power.
  • Proc damage or hand-specific proc behavior.
  • Haste rounding, minimum-delay rules, or other timer rounding.
  • Stances, invocations, disciplines, or temporary combat modifiers.
  • Encounter-specific weaknesses, resistances, or armor.

These omitted mechanics can change actual combat performance, especially when the calculator reports a close result.

Core Mechanics

Independent Weapon Timers

Confirmed on EverQuest Legends: the primary and secondary weapons use independent attack timers.

Each weapon uses its own delay. A fast secondary weapon can therefore reach multiple offhand attack opportunities before a slower primary weapon reaches its next attack.

Equipping a slower primary weapon does not directly slow the secondary weapon, and equipping a slower secondary weapon does not directly slow the primary weapon.

Offhand Attack Opportunities

When the secondary weapon's timer becomes ready, the game performs a Dual Wield check.

A successful check permits the secondary attack opportunity to proceed. A failed check produces no secondary attack for that timer cycle.

Higher Dual Wield skill therefore increases the percentage of secondary timer opportunities that become attacks. It does not change the secondary weapon's listed delay.

Damage Bonus Is a Separate Flat Addition

Weapon damage bonus is treated separately from the rolled weapon-damage portion of an attack.

STR, ATK, Offense, weapon skill, and target mitigation affect the variable weapon-damage roll. They do not directly determine the displayed weapon damage-bonus value.

Under the ordinary EverQuest hand model used by the calculator:

  • An eligible primary-hand attack receives the weapon's damage bonus.
  • The ordinary secondary-hand attack receives no damage bonus.
  • A two-handed primary weapon receives its own damage bonus.
  • Damage bonus is applied per eligible primary-hand hit.

This means the damage bonus must be calculated for the specific weapon placed in primary. It is not a single universal one-handed value.

Primary and Secondary Hand Assignment

At less than 100% Dual Wield chance, hand assignment matters because:

  1. The primary weapon attacks whenever its own timer is ready.
  2. The secondary weapon attacks only when its own timer is ready and the Dual Wield check succeeds.

The calculator therefore tests both hand assignments automatically.

In general, the stronger base weapon score becomes more valuable in primary as Dual Wield chance falls, because primary attacks are not reduced by the Dual Wield success check.

Primary-Hand Choice at High Dual Wield Chance

The higher the Dual Wield chance becomes, the less hand assignment matters because fewer offhand timer opportunities are lost.

Under the current Legends working chance model, a capped Monk at 252 Dual Wield skill has: 

252 ÷ 400 = 63.00% base chance

63.00% × 1.32 Ambidexterity
= 83.16% modeled chance

This means even a capped Monk with Ambidexterity is not currently expected to reach 100% Dual Wield chance.

Because the offhand is still losing some attack opportunities, the weapon with the stronger base (2 × Damage) ÷ Delay value will generally benefit from being placed in the primary hand.

Once Triple Attack is available, primary-hand placement becomes even more important because the primary weapon can receive Triple Attack and Burst of Power flurries while the offhand cannot.

The calculator nevertheless tests both arrangements because Damage Bonus, unusual weapon damage, delays above the Damage Bonus cap, and other hand-specific mechanics can affect the result.

Under the unrounded working Damage Bonus formula, ordinary one-handed weapons with damage at or below character level and delay at or below 50 receive approximately the same Damage Bonus contribution per unit time. For this reason, speculative integer Damage Bonus rounding should not normally override the advantage of putting the stronger-ratio weapon in primary.

Double Attack, Triple Attack, and Burst of Power

The calculator now includes additional melee attacks because Triple Attack is not available to the offhand and therefore does not cancel evenly between Dual Wield and two-handed setups.

Double Attack

Double Attack is modeled as available to both primary-hand and secondary-hand attack rounds.

The current working chance formula is: 

Double Attack Chance =
    (Character Level + Current Double Attack Skill)
    ÷ 500

The currently documented Legends acquisition levels and maximum skills are:

Class Minimum Level Maximum Skill
Monk 15 250
Warrior 15 245
Rogue 16 240
Paladin 20 235
Shadowknight 20 235
Ranger 20 235
Berserker 15 250

When Actual DA Skill is blank, the calculator provisionally uses Level × 5, capped by the class maximum. Entering the actual skill overrides this assumption.

Triple Attack

Current Legends observation: Triple Attack does not occur from the offhand.

The calculator therefore allows Triple Attack only on the primary hand and on two-handed attack rounds.

Class Minimum Level Maximum Skill
Monk 46 100
Warrior 46 100
Rogue 46 100
Ranger 46 100
Berserker 46 100

The current working chance is: 

Triple Attack Chance =
    Triple Attack Skill
    ÷ (Triple Attack Skill + 800)

Triple Attack is modeled as being checked only after a successful Double Attack.

Therefore: 

Expected primary / 2H attacks per timer opportunity =
    1
    + P(Double Attack)
    + P(Double Attack) × P(Triple Attack)

At 100 Triple Attack skill: 

100 ÷ (100 + 800)
= 11.11%

That 11.11% is conditional on Double Attack already succeeding.

When Actual TA Skill is blank, the calculator provisionally models 5 skill points per level beginning at level 46, capped at 100. Entering the actual skill overrides this assumption.

Burst of Power / Flurry

Burst of Power is available as a calculator checkbox.

The current working interpretation is:

  • Flurry is checked only after a successful Triple Attack.
  • Burst of Power grants a 15% chance to flurry.
  • A successful flurry produces either one or two additional attacks.
  • The calculator assumes a 50% chance of either outcome.

The expected flurry contribution per successful Triple Attack is: 

0.15 × (0.50 × 1 + 0.50 × 2)
= 0.225 extra attacks

With Burst of Power enabled: 

Primary / 2H multiplier =
    1
    + P(DA)
    + P(DA) × P(TA) × 1.225

The offhand receives Double Attack but does not receive Triple Attack or this Triple-Attack-triggered flurry in the current model: 

Offhand multiplier =
    1 + P(Double Attack)

This creates a real post-level-46 disadvantage for the offhand relative to the primary hand and a two-handed weapon.

Shared Modifiers

A modifier that affects both compared setups by the same proportion does not change which setup wins a normalized comparison.

Ordinary haste is therefore omitted from the calculator when the same haste applies to all compared weapons.

STR and ATK are also omitted from the simple comparison because the calculator is intended as a target-neutral weapon comparison rather than a complete melee simulator. A full expected-DPS model would require the attacker's combat statistics, the target's mitigation and avoidance, weapon skills, and the damage-roll distribution.

Working Legends Damage Bonus Model

EverQuest damage-bonus formulas have changed over time.

The older classic-era one-handed formula and historical two-handed lookup tables do not match observed EverQuest Legends damage bonuses well.

The calculator therefore uses a later/live EverQuest damage-bonus formula published by a Daybreak developer. This model closely matches the currently observed Legends values across a range of one-handed and two-handed weapon delays.

The working formula is: 

Damage Bonus =
    Hand Modifier
    × max(Character Level, Weapon Damage)
    × (min(Weapon Delay, 50) ÷ 40)
    × (Character Level ÷ 100)

Where:

  • 1H Hand Modifier = 0.8
  • 2H Hand Modifier = 1.1
  • Weapon delay contributes only up to 50 delay.
  • If weapon damage exceeds character level, weapon damage is used instead of character level for that portion of the formula.
  • Damage bonus begins at level 28 in the reference implementation.

The exact Legends integer rounding rule has not yet been proven.

For weapon comparison, the calculator therefore uses the unrounded working Damage Bonus value internally: 

Modifier
× max(Level, Damage)
× (min(Delay, 50) ÷ 40)
× (Level ÷ 100)

This avoids allowing a speculative rounding rule to determine which one-handed weapon should be placed in primary. The calculator may display an integer Damage Bonus estimate for readability, but the normalized comparison itself uses the raw modeled value.

Why Delay Matters

Unlike the older classic one-handed damage-bonus formula, the newer formula scales the damage bonus with weapon delay.

This explains why two one-handed weapons at the same character level can display different damage bonuses and why slower two-handed weapons can receive much larger bonuses.

Because delay contribution caps at 50:

  • Increasing delay from 20 to 40 increases modeled damage bonus.
  • Increasing delay from 50 to 70 does not increase the delay portion further.
  • A weapon with damage greater than character level can still receive a larger bonus because the formula uses max(Level, Damage).

Classes and Skill Caps on Legends

The calculator recognizes the following classes as Dual Wield-granting classes:

On a three-class character, the calculator uses the highest applicable Dual Wield cap supplied by any selected class. Class caps are not added together.

The current working level-50 cap model is:

Class Working per-level formula Modeled cap through level 50 Status
Bard (Level × 5) + 5 210 Working model
Beastlord (Level × 5) + 5 210 Working model
Monk (Level × 7) + 5 252 Supported by observed caps of 89 at level 12 and 96 at level 13
Ranger (Level × 5) + 5 210 Working model
Rogue (Level × 6) + 5 210 Working model
Warrior (Level × 5) + 5 210 Working model

The class-specific cap is applied after the per-level calculation.

For example, the observed Monk progression is: 

Level 12: (12 × 7) + 5 = 89
Level 13: (13 × 7) + 5 = 96

The calculator assumes the character's Dual Wield skill is trained to the applicable cap unless an actual skill value is entered.

Era-Dependent and Unconfirmed Mechanics

The following mechanics have changed between EverQuest eras or differ among community servers and emulator implementations. Their exact behavior on EverQuest Legends should be confirmed directly rather than inherited from another era.

Current Dual Wield Chance Model

The exact server formula has not been proven from source code, but direct Legends parsing now gives a substantially better working model than the inherited historical formulas.

The calculator currently uses: 

Base Dual Wield Chance =
    Current Dual Wield Skill ÷ 400

Character level is not added directly to the numerator in this model.

Level still matters indirectly because it determines how much Dual Wield skill the character can obtain.

For a Monk with 252 Dual Wield skill: 

252 ÷ 400 = 63.00%

With the current Ambidexterity working model: 

63.00% × 1.32 = 83.16%

Legends Parse Evidence

A level-50 Monk with:

  • 252 Dual Wield skill
  • Ambidexterity
  • 27-delay primary weapon
  • 28-delay secondary weapon
  • +50% haste

produced a parse of approximately:

  • 1,057 primary-hand pierce swings
  • 860 offhand punches

The small 27-versus-28 delay difference is nowhere near large enough to explain the observed swing-count gap by itself.

After accounting approximately for the independent 27/28 weapon timers, the parse implies an offhand success rate in the low-to-mid 80% range.

That is inconsistent with the previous calculator model: 

(Level + Skill) ÷ 400 × 1.32

which predicted almost 100% for a capped level-50 Monk.

It is instead closely consistent with: 

Skill ÷ 400 × 1.32

which predicts: 

252 ÷ 400 × 1.32
= 83.16%

This remains a working Legends formula rather than a proven server-side equation, but it is currently the model best supported by direct in-game evidence.

Historical formulas such as (Level + Skill) ÷ 400, the Project 1999 Warrior ÷475 estimate, and current EQEmu implementations should therefore be treated as historical references rather than the active Legends calculator model.

Ambidexterity

Confirmed on EverQuest Legends: Ambidexterity is listed as increasing successful Dual Wield chance by 32%.

The calculator currently treats that value as a multiplicative increase: 

Effective Dual Wield Chance =
    Base Dual Wield Chance × 1.32

This interpretation is not proven from Legends source code, but when paired with the skill-only base formula it closely matches current parse evidence.

For a capped Monk: 

Base:
252 ÷ 400
= 63.00%

With Ambidexterity:
63.00% × 1.32
= 83.16%

Additional controlled parses without Ambidexterity would be especially useful for separating the base Dual Wield formula from the exact Ambidexterity implementation.

Exact Damage-Bonus Formula and Rounding

The later/live formula used by the calculator is currently the best match to observed Legends damage bonuses.

However, Legends-specific confirmation is still needed for:

  • exact integer rounding or truncation,
  • whether level 28 is the exact activation level,
  • whether the 0.8 and 1.1 handedness modifiers are identical on Legends,
  • whether the 50-delay cap is identical,
  • whether all multiclass combinations receive damage bonus identically,
  • whether any Legends AA, stance, invocation, or item effect grants secondary-hand damage bonus.

The older classic formula: 

floor((Level − 25) ÷ 3)

and historical two-handed lookup tables should be treated as historical mechanics, not as the current Legends calculator model.

Additional-Attack Formula Verification

Double Attack, Triple Attack, and Burst of Power are now included in the calculator using the working formulas above.

The following still need direct Legends verification:

  • Exact Double Attack probability formula and divisor.
  • Exact per-level Double Attack caps.
  • Exact Triple Attack probability formula.
  • Exact per-level Triple Attack caps.
  • Confirmation across eligible multiclass combinations that Triple Attack remains primary-only.
  • Exact Burst of Power fourth/fifth-swing procedure.
  • Any AA, item, discipline, or stance that changes additional-attack eligibility by hand.

Proc Rates

Proc damage is not included because proc behavior may differ by:

  • primary versus secondary hand,
  • weapon delay,
  • Dexterity,
  • proc-per-minute normalization,
  • Legends-specific item or AA effects.

A weaker normalized weapon score can still produce better actual DPS when its proc contribution is sufficiently strong.

Skill Acquisition Levels

Historical class tables disagree about the level at which several classes acquire Dual Wield.

EverQuest Legends multiclassing also differs from historical EverQuest.

The calculator therefore assumes the character already possesses Dual Wield and focuses on the applicable skill cap.

Post-Level-50 Skill Caps

Historical EverQuest sources commonly list later caps such as:

  • Bard: 210
  • Beastlord: 210
  • Monk: 252
  • Ranger: 240
  • Rogue: 245
  • Warrior: 240

These should not be treated as confirmed future Legends caps. They should be retested if the Legends level cap increases.

Empty-Hand and Primary-Slot Requirements

Historical implementations have differed in their treatment of an empty primary slot, Hand to Hand, and secondary-only weapons.

The following should be tested directly on Legends:

  • Whether a non-Monk can attack with a secondary weapon while primary is empty.
  • Whether a Monk can use an empty primary hand with a secondary weapon.
  • Whether an empty secondary slot can still trigger Dual Wield checks.
  • Whether Hand to Hand uses the same independent-timer behavior as equipped weapons.

Legends Verification Priorities

The highest-priority remaining tests are:

  1. Dual Wield chance: repeat long primary/offhand swing-count parses at several known Dual Wield skill values to test the current Skill ÷ 400 model.
  2. Ambidexterity: repeat the same controlled parse with and without Ambidexterity to verify the current multiplicative ×1.32 model.
  3. Damage bonus rounding: record level, weapon damage, delay, handedness, and displayed damage bonus for many weapons.
  4. Damage bonus activation: test levels immediately below and above level 28.
  5. Double Attack: parse characters with known DA skill values to test (Level + Skill) ÷ 500 and confirm offhand Double Attack.
  6. Triple Attack: record primary attack-round distributions at several known TA skill values to test Skill ÷ (Skill + 800).
  7. Triple Attack hand rule: continue checking offhand logs to confirm that Triple Attack never occurs from secondary.
  8. Burst of Power: measure fourth- and fifth-swing frequencies after successful Triple Attacks to determine the exact flurry procedure.
  9. Class skill caps: record displayed caps by level for every Dual Wield-granting class.

For Dual Wield testing, attempted swings should be distinguished from successful hits whenever possible because hit rate is separate from the Dual Wield check.

References

Spell: Abjuration • Alteration • Channeling • Conjuration • Divination • Evocation • Meditate • Specialization
Specialize: Abjuration • Specialize: Alteration • Specialize: Conjuration • Specialize: Divination • Specialize: Evocation
Weapon: 1H Blunt • 1H Slash • 2H Blunt • 2H Slash • 2H Piercing • Archery • Piercing • Throwing
Combat: Bash • Block • Cleave • Defense • Disarm • Dodge • Double Attack • Dual Wield • Hand to Hand • Harm Touch
Intimidation • Kick • Lay on Hands • Offense • Parry • Reave • Riposte • Slam • Smite • Taunt • Triple Attack
Rogue: Backstab • Disarm Traps • Pick Lock • Pick Pocket • Sense Traps
Monk: Dragon Punch • Eagle Strike • Feign Death • Flying Kick • Mend • Round Kick • Safe Fall • Tail Rake (Iksar) • Tiger Claw
Bard: Brass Instruments • Percussion • Singing • Stringed Instruments • Wind Instruments
Non-Combat: Alcohol Tolerance • Athletics • Begging • Bind Wound • Gather Party • Fishing • Foraging • Hide (Evade) • Origin • Sense Heading • Sneak • Swimming • Tracking
Retrieved from "https://eqlwiki.com/index.php?title=Skill_Dual_Wield&oldid=171562"